The Fantasticks / Cast Alix Ogawa The Fantasticks Mute Audrey Curd A Man of No Importance Adele Rice The Fantasticks Luisa Christopher Karbo The Fantasticks El Gallo Joey D’Auria The Fantasticks Henry Matt Franta A Man of No Importance Breton Beret Peter Barrymore Frank The Fantasticks Matt Matt Stevens A Man of No Importance Baldy O'Shea The Fantasticks Hucklebee Michael Loupé A Man of No Importance Carson Rasher Flynn The Fantasticks Mortimer Michael P. Wallot A Man of No Importance Ernie Lally Closer Than Ever Marry Me A Little Marketing & Media Manager The Fantasticks Bellomy The Toxic Avenger