The Toxic Avenger Musical / Cast Danny Fetter The Toxic Avenger Jared Reed The Toxic Avenger Melyvin Ferd The Third Toxic Avenger Kim Dalton The Toxic Avenger Sarah Michael P. Wallot A Man of No Importance Ernie Lally Closer Than Ever Marry Me A Little Marketing & Media Manager The Fantasticks Bellomy The Toxic Avenger Shirley Anne Hatton A Man of No Importance Lily Byrne The Toxic Avenger Ma Ferd Mayor Babs Belgoody Nun Wesley Tunison White Dude